I don't think I come across great online. I mean I like to think I'm pretty funny in person (and hopefully in print!) and I just think I'm trying too hard in my profile. Whatever. It's just like auditions or interviews - I'm much better in person. It's just getting to that point that seems to be an issue.
For those of you not familiar with online dating - here's a quick rundown about how it works for me.
First thing I notice when I get matched is where someone lives. I don't have a car, so people who live in Reston or Gaithersburg may be looked at after someone who lives in DC proper or Arlington/Bethesda etc. Also, I get a ton of matches from people who live near Baltimore or down towards Woodbridge. That is geographically undesirable for me. I've heard it all - don't email me. I realize that this cuts out a lot of people, but I like to date closer to where I live.
The next thing, I notice, of course are the photos. If there are no photos posted, that guy immediately gets the boot. Sorry dudes - it's 2009. Pictures are no longer an option when you are online dating - they are a requirement. I realize that photos are not a very good judge of how someone actually looks in person but you can get a general gist.
Then I read their profile. At this point, I'm looking for someone who is witty, maybe a little funny and clearly doesn't take themselves to seriously. Also - I'm looking at their interests/hobbies as well. If it's a guy who runs triathalons and is looking for someone to share that hobby with - well, that's not my lazy ass. I'll look at their job as well - though that matters less to me. They just need to be gainfully employed.
Other things I look for are kids (also an automatic dealbreaker for me), height (not usually that picky, but they have to be taller than me - 5'6"+, you would be surprised at how short some people are) whether they have pets and anything they might list.
Generally, I find that I'm the intiator for contact. This used to bother me a lot more - but I've stopped caring. I have a list of people and I like to weed them out one way or another. Also, if someone doesn't respond either positively or negatively within a matter of time, I probably wouldn't have been interested in them in the long run. I like men of action. :)
Then the laborious process of questions and relationship pro/cons start - and finally, if it all works out you progress to email and then hopefully a face-to-face meeting. And the first email, first phone call and first face-to-face meeting is a whole OTHER can of worms, or at the very least - another post.
Next post: my first date after the post-boyfriend hiatus.